Key takeaways
- Compare electric roaster ovens by capacity, turkey size, temperature range and lid style, from a compact 6-quart Nesco to 22-quart holiday roasters.
An electric roaster oven is a countertop appliance with its own covered cooking cavity, and it earns its keep whenever the main oven is already spoken for. On a holiday, that means the turkey roasts in the roaster while casseroles and pies take turns in the range. The rest of the year, the same appliance handles hams, pork shoulders, baked potatoes and big batches of chili without heating the whole kitchen the way a full-size oven does.
The five roasters below span the sizes home cooks actually buy, from a compact 6-quart model to 22-quart ovens rated for very large turkeys. Each one has a removable pan or cookwell and a simple temperature dial, and the differences that matter are capacity, lid design, temperature range and footprint. Read the specs closely, because a quart rating alone does not tell you whether a tall bird will fit under the lid.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Quick Answer
For most holiday hosts, a 22-quart roaster such as the Hamilton Beach or the AROMA ART-712SB adds a second oven that fits a large turkey and frees the range for sides. If you cook smaller meals, the 6-quart Nesco 4816-14 covers everyday roasts without taking over the counter.
Hamilton Beach 28 Lb Turkey Roaster 22 Quart Oven
This is the largest cavity in the group, and the pick for hosts who cook for a crowd. Hamilton Beach rates the 22-quart oven for a turkey up to 28 pounds, which makes it a true second oven on holidays. The enamel-on-steel pan lifts out for cleaning and serving, and a lift-out rack helps you remove a heavy bird without wrestling it out of a deep well.
The listing describes full-range, oven-style temperature settings that cover roasting, baking, steaming and slow cooking, so the same unit can bake a casserole or keep a pork shoulder low and slow. The trade-off is size: at about 25 inches wide, it needs real counter space while it runs and a serious storage spot the rest of the year.
Specs
- Capacity: 22 quarts
- Turkey rating: up to 28 lb (maker rating)
- Pan: removable enamel-on-steel pan
- Rack: lift-out roasting rack included
- Dimensions: 18 x 25.25 x 11.13 inches
- Model: 32235
- Temperature range and wattage: confirm on the listing
AROMA 22Qt. Roaster Oven with Self-Basting Lid (ART-712SB)
The AROMA ART-712SB matches the Hamilton Beach on capacity but adds a self-basting lid, which is shaped to redirect condensation back over the food as it cooks. AROMA rates the 22-quart cavity for a turkey up to 26 pounds, and the dial runs from 150 to 450 degrees Fahrenheit, with defrost and keep-warm settings that stretch its usefulness beyond roasting day.
Inside, the enameled steel pan removes for cleaning and a metal rack lifts roasts clear of the drippings. At 22 inches long it is a little shorter than the Hamilton Beach, which can matter on a crowded counter. AROMA also sells individual replacement parts for this model, including the insert pan and rack. Choose this one if you want the big capacity plus the low warming range and the self-basting lid.
Specs
- Capacity: 22 quarts
- Turkey rating: up to 26 lb (maker rating)
- Temperature range: 150 to 450 degrees Fahrenheit
- Power: 1,450 watts
- Lid: self-basting lid
- Pan: removable enameled steel pan with metal rack
- Settings: defrost and keep warm, plus roasting and baking
- Dimensions: 22 x 15.75 x 12.5 inches
Nesco MWR18-13 Roaster Oven, 18 Quarts, Black
Nesco has made roaster ovens for decades, and the MWR18-13 is its straightforward 18-quart workhorse. The removable cookwell is rated for a whole turkey up to 22 pounds, and the temperature dial covers 200 to 450 degrees Fahrenheit, which handles roasting, baking and slow cooking for family-size meals without extra settings to manage.
The black finish and simple control keep the focus on capacity per inch of counter: it is about 24 inches wide, so it stores more easily than the 22-quart models while still covering most holiday birds. One honest limitation is the 200-degree floor on the dial, which makes this a weaker choice if you want a roaster that doubles as a low-temperature warmer for serving. If your goal is a proven mid-size roaster for turkeys, hams and big casseroles, without warming or defrost settings, this is the simple option in the group.
Specs
- Capacity: 18 quarts
- Turkey rating: up to 22 lb (maker rating)
- Temperature range: 200 to 450 degrees Fahrenheit
- Cookwell: removable 18-quart cookwell
- Dimensions: 15.75 x 24 x 12.75 inches
- Weight: 14 lb
- Model: MWR18-13
- Color: black
Oster Roaster Oven with Self-Basting Lid, 18 Quart, Black (CKSTRS18-BSB-W)
The Oster pairs the 18-quart size with the same self-basting lid idea as the larger AROMA: the lid continually recirculates moisture over the food, so you open the roaster less often and lose less heat. Oster rates it for a turkey or roast up to 22 pounds, and the temperature range runs from 150 to 450 degrees Fahrenheit, a wider span than the Nesco 18-quart model.
The removable enamel-on-steel roasting pan and steel roasting rack cover serving and cleanup, and at about 9.7 inches tall it is the lowest-profile 18-quart pick here, which helps under wall cabinets. It roasts, bakes and slow cooks, so it can take over a Sunday pot roast as readily as a holiday bird. Pick the Oster if you want the self-basting lid and the low 150-degree setting in the mid-size class.
Specs
- Capacity: 18 quarts
- Turkey rating: up to 22 lb (maker rating)
- Temperature range: 150 to 450 degrees Fahrenheit
- Lid: self-basting lid
- Pan: removable enamel-on-steel roasting pan
- Rack: steel roasting rack included
- Dimensions: 17.5 x 24.4 x 9.7 inches
- Model: CKSTRS18-BSB-W
Nesco 6 Qt. Porcelain Roaster Oven, White, 4816-14
Not every roaster needs to swallow a turkey. The Nesco 4816-14 is a 6-quart countertop roaster sized for small households: the maker says the removable cookwell serves up to six people, which translates to a whole chicken, a small beef or pork roast, a casserole or a batch of baked potatoes. It roasts, bakes, cooks, steams and serves, so it can stand in for the oven on ordinary weeknights.
Nesco’s Circle of Heat element wraps the sides of the cookwell rather than heating only from below, and the dial runs from 200 to 450 degrees Fahrenheit on 750 watts. The porcelain-enamel cookwell lifts out and is dishwasher safe, and the roughly 15-inch square footprint is far easier to store than any big roaster here. The limit is obvious: there is no whole-turkey cooking in a 6-quart well. For couples, small families and second-oven duty for side dishes, that trade is often the right one.
Specs
- Capacity: 6 quarts
- Serves: up to 6 people (maker rating)
- Temperature range: 200 to 450 degrees Fahrenheit
- Power: 750 watts
- Heating element: Circle of Heat side element
- Cookwell: removable porcelain-enamel cookwell, dishwasher safe
- Weight: 8 lb
- Model: 4816-14
- Color: white
How to Choose Electric Roaster Ovens
Start with the largest thing you realistically cook. Turkey ratings matter more than quart counts: the 18-quart models here are rated around 22 pounds, the 22-quart models for 26 to 28 pounds, and a tall bird can fail to fit under the lid even when the weight looks fine, so check the maker’s rating and your usual bird size together.
Next, look at the temperature range. A dial that starts at 125 or 150 degrees Fahrenheit can hold food warm and slow cook gently, while a 200-degree floor is fine for roasting but limiting for serving. A 450-degree top end matters if you want to bake or brown. Then consider the lid: self-basting lids recycle moisture and reduce how often you open the roaster, while plain lids are simpler and often lighter.
Finally, measure twice. These are large appliances, roughly 24 to 25 inches wide in the big sizes, and they need clearance while running plus a storage home afterward. Removable pans make cleanup and serving much easier, and enamel or porcelain coatings can chip if knocked, so handle them with care. Higher-wattage models draw substantial power, so run one on a circuit that is not already carrying other heavy appliances, and follow the maker’s instructions for placement and use.
Who Should Skip Electric Roaster Ovens
Skip a roaster oven if your oven already handles your biggest meals with room to spare, because a 22-quart appliance is a storage commitment that pays off only a few times a year. Cooks in small kitchens may be better served by a Dutch oven or a large toaster oven that earns daily use.
Also skip this category if you want precise digital temperature control and timers; the roasters here are simple dial appliances, and their accuracy depends on the dial and your own thermometer. And if you cook only for one or two people and never host, even the 6-quart Nesco may be more appliance than you need compared with a small slow cooker you already own.
FAQ
Can an electric roaster oven replace a regular oven for a holiday meal?
It can take over the main dish, which is usually the biggest space problem, but it is still a single cavity. Plan the menu so the roaster handles the turkey or ham while the range covers sides, or the other way around. Follow the maker’s cooking chart and check doneness with a food thermometer rather than relying on time alone.
What size roaster oven do I need for a turkey?
Match the maker’s turkey rating to the bird you actually buy, not just the quart count. In this group, 18-quart models are rated for birds up to about 22 pounds and 22-quart models for 26 to 28 pounds. Remember that a tall, broad bird may not fit under the lid even within the weight rating, so allow some margin.
Do roaster ovens cook faster than a regular oven?
Not reliably enough to plan around. The smaller cavity can preheat quickly, but cooking times still follow the recipe and the maker’s chart for the size and weight of the food. Treat any time savings as a bonus, keep the lid closed as much as the instructions allow, and let a thermometer decide when the food is done.
Are the pans and cookwells easy to clean?
All five picks have removable pans or cookwells, which is the feature that matters most at cleanup time. Porcelain and enamel finishes generally wash in the sink, and the small Nesco cookwell is listed as dishwasher safe; check the listing for each model’s exact guidance. Avoid metal utensils on enamel coatings and let the pan cool before washing to protect the finish.
Final Verdict
For a true second oven, the Hamilton Beach 22-quart and the AROMA ART-712SB lead this group, with the AROMA adding a self-basting lid, defrost and keep-warm settings. In the 18-quart class, the Oster brings the same self-basting idea and a lower temperature floor, while the Nesco MWR18-13 keeps things simple. And for small households, the 6-quart Nesco 4816-14 is the rare roaster sized for everyday cooking instead of once-a-year birds. Match the turkey rating and footprint to your kitchen first.
Worth a look next
- Best Electric Coffee Roasters for Fresh Beans at Home
- Best Electric Quesadilla Makers for Fast Weeknight Meals
- Best Electric Lunch Boxes: 5 Heated Picks for Hot Meals
- Best Electric Food Steamers: 5 Top Picks for Healthy Meals
- Best Meat Slicers: 5 Electric Deli Slicers for Home Use
- Best Electric Tea Kettles With Temperature Control: 5 Picks